True Romance: got consent?

1

Image Credit: http://miraclemiledeli.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Happy-Valentines-Day.jpeg

This Valentine’s Day, folks across the country will be either ignoring the romantic vibes altogether, deriding the holiday, praising the single life, celebrating an ongoing romance, or trying to start a new one. For folks seeking out companionship, relationships can be a minefield, as can sexual behavior. What does this have to do with bioethics, you ask?

Sexual behavior is one of the many ways that things can go wrong—or right!—in human relationships. Even sex-positive approaches to human relationships necessarily involve considerations ranging from physical health (safe sex and prevention of sexually transmitted infections) to mental health (how relationships end, mutually shared expectations, the PTSD and depression commonly experienced after sexual assault).

To prevent the worst health effects of sexual behavior, participants must have a fundamental respect for each other’s autonomy and for each other as persons. The Missouri case of a man who exposed over 300 people to HIV through unprotected sex without taking preventive measures or informing his partners, is an example of lack of respect for others’ autonomy and for them as persons.  It is not really autonomous consent if you don’t know what you are getting into, even if you say yes.

It is sometimes tempting as a bioethicist to view calls to privilege autonomy with some skepticism, especially as autonomy can conflict with beneficence, non-maleficence, confidentiality, fidelity, justice, and other major principles of medicine and nursing.  Classically in American bioethics, autonomy was given significant ordinal priority over other principles in order to counter the abuses of unnecessary paternalism.  But a nuanced and careful view of ethics may sometimes place autonomy second to other principles.

When it comes to sexual conduct, however, the autonomy of each participant must be unquestioned and unquestionable.  Autonomy doesn’t so much trump all other principles as it enrolls them in bolstering it, in part because the harms of overriding it are so severe. These harms include PTSD, substance abuse, self-harm/self-injury, sleep disorders, eating disorders, suicide, and depression.  It may be one (problematic) thing for a physician to say “This patient doesn’t know what he wants because no matter how hard I try to explain the risks and benefits, he still doesn’t understand.” It is something else altogether for someone to say of an intended sexual partner who refuses advances, “She doesn’t know what she wants.”

Semenax Medication to Increase Sperm Production Volume pills like Semenax have been developed by health experts who have been supporting the proper utilization of such medicinal treatments for getting rid over impotency & it is also found that this ingredient is effective in enhancing spermatogenesis, which is the corner buy generic levitra stone for sexual reproduction. I’ve written about the seminal influence in buy female viagra my life when I have not read to learn something or to entertain myself. Joint Replacement Surgery Replacement surgery or replacement arthroplasty cialis 40 mg http://robertrobb.com/should-aps-be-in-the-low-income-loan-business/ is an orthopedic surgery procedure where dysfunctional joint surface is replaced with an orthopaedic prosthesis. This popular and cialis online cheapest effective erectile dysfunction medicine is not only good for your sex life but also injures the male psyche to a great extent. Valentine’s Day is an excellent time to remember that the health consequences of sexual behaviors, including sexual assault and rape, are indeed concerns for not only the ethics of human relationships but also medical ethics. Let’s give some thought to this at this time of year, as San Francisco’s “One Billion Rising for Justice Day” does. One Billion Rising began in 2013, and now spans 207 countries, to raise awareness of domestic and sexual abuse against women.  Certainly we need more awareness, as the victims and offenders are not always who we think they are.

2

Image Credit: CNN.com

 

3

Image Credit: CNN.com

Talking about sexual assault and safe sex on Valentine’s Day may seem singularly unromantic.  But lack of genuine consent, whether due to misinformation by a partner or refusing to take no for an answer or not waiting for yes, well, that is truly unromantic.  I won’t go so far as to echo the new saying that “consent is sexy”, as that is a loaded claim.

But true romance can’t happen without it.

Share Button

Comments

True Romance: got consent? — 2 Comments

  1. Thanks for the post, Alison!

    Since you mention the one billion rising movement, I thought I would add that this is also the Global Day for Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women. Lots of marches and memorial events have been going on around this for some time, but there’s also been some criticism of the V-Day/Eve Ensler/One Billion Rising movements for overshadowing the work of (while claiming to speak for) indigenous anti-violence activists. For instance:
    http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2014/02/14/feb-14-not-v-day-its-global-day-missing-murdered-indigenous-women-153576

    This is much more a friendly amendment than a critique of your post, but I think an important piece of our thinking about sexual assault is how it disproportionately affects different communities.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.